Culture Cinema & Tv Show reviews

Mayflies

Mayflies | Show review

As teenagers, James and Tully bonded over a shared desire to make it out of the small Scottish village they grew up in, James via writing, Tully through his music. Some thirty years later, James is called back to their home town for a meeting, which leaves his world shattered. Tully not only discloses that he has been diagnosed with terminal cancer with a remaining life expectancy of a few months: he wants James to be his “campaign manager” to travel to a clinic in Switzerland, specialised in assisted dying.

The source material behind this BBC adaptation is Andrew O’Hagan’s autobiographically inspired novel Mayflies, which won the Book Prize of the Los Angeles Times in 2020.

While the book’s narrative is split into two timelines, the show is primarily set in the present, with repeated flashbacks juxtaposing the adult protagonist’s evanescence with the brazen sense of immortality experienced in his youth. Sporadically, archival images are spliced into the memories, and pop culture references to music, films and football flesh out both worlds.

With its focus on male friendship, the show offers a stirring concomitant portrayal of vulnerability, self-determination and bodily autonomy. None of these themes necessarily spark an immediate association with the usual depiction of men on screen, but down to the sentimental and reflective elements, the story is told in an entirely unconstrained and veracious manner.

The casting is simply sublime: many of the young actors and their older counterparts bear a striking physical resemblance or manage to capture the exact same essence of their character. With his riveting performance as free-spirited Tully, Tony Curran, whose CV lists supporting roles in the three-digit range, clarifies once and for all that he is leading man material.

As a television two-parter, Mayflies feels a little stuck between a proper miniseries and a two-hour film; both formats could have brought their own set of advantages. In their current state, the episodes sadly don’t always make the best use of their limited time.

Selina Sondermann

Mayflies is released on BBC iPlayer on 27th December 2022.

Watch the trailer for Mayflies here:

More in Shows

Nicole Kidman and Jamie Lee Curtis bring Patricia Cornwell’s forensic icon to life in Prime Video’s Scarpetta

The editorial unit

Sean Combs: The Reckoning – Explosive four-part documentary lands on Netflix this December

The editorial unit

Kristen Stewart steps behind the camera for powerful debut The Chronology of Water, in cinemas February 2026

The editorial unit

Joanna Lumley, Richard Curtis and Beatles family attend exclusive screening of The Beatles Anthology at BFI Southbank

The editorial unit

“I just find it mad, but also incredibly exciting”: Ellis Howard on BAFTA Breakthrough

Sarah Bradbury

Power, paranoia and deepfakes: Holliday Grainger returns in first look at The Capture series thre

The editorial unit

Nia DaCosta directs 28 Years Later: The Bone Temple, a brutal evolution of the horror series

The editorial unit

Universal

Andrew Murray

Richard Gere and Jacob Elordi star in Paul Schrader’s introspective new drama Oh, Canada

The editorial unit